Will Scots vote “yes” on independence?

Scottish independence would be a terrible loss for the UK

By Natalie Beale
Scarlet Staff

The current debate for Scottish independence began with the Scottish Parliament general election of May 2011, where the Scottish National Party(SNP) gained a majority of 69 seats out of 128. Party leader

Scotland's First Minister and leader of the Scottish National Party Alex Salmond, Photo courtesy of csmonitor.com, David Moir/Reuters

Alex Salmond has been First Minister of Scotland since 2007. Given that this is the first majority for a Scottish government since 1999, it no doubt gave Salmond the confidence to announce that a referendum for Scottish independence would take place in Autumn 2014.

Currently, the Scottish Parliament can make its own laws regarding matters such as education, health, agriculture and justice. Other matters are reserved for the UK Parliament in Westminster, such as major tax laws, foreign policy and social security. As part of the UK, Scotland naturally votes for that Parliament as well as their own.

Opinion polls suggest that the Scots are marginally in favor of remaining within the UK, and Prime Minster David Cameron has expressed a strong desire for Scotland to stay. In a visit to Edinburgh this month, he considered offering the Scottish Parliament further powers of self-governance. In any case, Cameron wants to see the referendum take place sooner rather than later.

The UK population is 60 million, and the Scots make up 5 million of that number. To lose them would make the definition of “British” even smaller, and leave Scotland as an independent country with a population smaller than that of Massachusetts. The UK has the seventh largest economy, proving the strength of this union – would Scotland damage its economy by voting “yes” to independence?

Historically England (and to a far lesser extent Wales) has been in conflict with Scotland, although that rivalry is now limited soccer. Scotland has a distinctive national culture, but it is also entwined with the culture of Britain as a whole. The last Prime Minister, Gordon Brown, was Scottish – but British at the same time. Scots are a part of the union, they are the largest non-English group living in England. Would they become ‘foreigners’ if Scotland seceded?

Scotland plays a major role in UK politics, and historically has always voted left-wing. In the 2010 UK general election, the Labour Party (led by Gordon Brown) was dethroned in the midst of a weak economy. No other party managed to win a majority, so a coalition between the Liberal Democrats (Lib Dems) and the Conservatives (Tories) was formed. Tory leader David Cameron became PM, and Lib Dem leader Nick Clegg became Deputy PM. Lost confidence in left-wing Labour was divided between the Lib Dems, and in Scotland, a turn towards the SNP. When the left-wing vote is united behind Labour, Scotland is an important ally in electing a liberal government. To emphasize Scotland’s left-wing blood, it is important to know that the Conservatives don’t even bother campaigning up there.

The current ‘coalition’ government (the Lib Dems are just a bauble and/or scapegoat to the Conservatives), led by David “shiny face” Cameron, has already left its mark. University tuition fees have trebled, libraries have been closed, arts funding has been slashed, the last 18% of publicly owned forest will be sold to private owners, and the National Health Service is under threat of ‘reforms’ widely condemned by health professionals and patients. For left-wing Brits, the Scottish are needed not just for their sparkling wit, astonishing good looks and general loveliness, but to elect the best government available.

Scotland is a vital piece – the head, in fact – of British politics, society, culture and identity. This small country has given the world penicillin, microwaves, radar, and refrigerators. It has given Britain a number of Prime Ministers, a Time Lord and a sense of being whole. Plus, let’s face one sad fact: to the rest of the world, the accents are basically indistinguishable.

One thought on “Will Scots vote “yes” on independence?

  1. There are some words or phrases used in relation to Scotland which can cause confusion They are 1. “seceded”, 2. “Britain” and “British”, and 3. “United Kingdom (UK).

    1. The words “seceded” or “secession” do not apply to Scotland in the normal sense of the words.

    2. The term “Britain” and “British” tend to be confused when no distinction is made between the poitical and social sense of the terms. In the political sense Scotland has only been part of Britain and its people British since May 1, 1707 (see Article 1 of the Treaty of Union in 1707).

    3. There is a widespread misunderstanding about what the United Kingdom (UK) actually is.

    There are a number of posts on my blog “THE ‘SANITIZATION’ OF SCOTTISH HISTORY” – http://follonblogs.blogspot.com/, one of which is titled “Understanding Scottish Independence”.

    Michael Follon,

Leave a comment:

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s